Effortless Baked Feta Pasta

This smooth and zesty trend that took over kitchens everywhere finally made an appearance at my house after I kept seeing it all over TikTok. I couldn't ignore it anymore, so I gave in and tried this famous baked feta pasta everyone was raving about. What blew me away was how simple it is—juicy tomatoes and a chunk of feta get all melty in the oven, creating a rich sauce that hugs every noodle. It’s hardly any work, yet the taste feels like something way fancier than your usual quick dinner.

When I gave this a go for the first time last summer, my whole place smelled like roasting tomatoes and fresh herbs. My partner, who normally doubts anything trendy, kept sneaking bites of the warm, cheesy mix straight from the pan. Now, it’s part of our usual meals, and we love mixing it up with new extras each time.

Vibrant Main Ingredients

• Pasta of your choice: This is perfect for soaking up all that dreamy sauce and catching the tasty bits
• Fresh basil tossed in last: Gives a pop of green and freshness that keeps things from getting too heavy
• Italian seasoning: A handy way to get a bunch of yummy herbs in the mix without dragging out a bunch of little jars
• Extra virgin olive oil: Adds body and helps caramelize the tomatoes while keeping the cheese smooth
• A chunk of good feta cheese: The MVP that gets gooey and tangy, taking every bite up a notch
• Cherry or grape tomatoes: Roasted, they burst open and sweeten the whole thing

Simple Step Gameplan

Pasta Merge:

Grab your just-boiled pasta (around 10 ounces), mix in a splash of saved pasta water and toss in fresh basil leaves so they're coated in that hot, savory sauce.

Mash-Up Magic:

Out comes the pan—start mixing right away, gently breaking up those tomatoes and feta so everything gets super silky and a little chunky at the same time.

Bake Until Golden:

Slide your dish into the oven, uncovered, for about 35 minutes. Watch for the tomatoes to slump and take on color, and the feta to get golden on top.

Shower with Flavor:

Top your setup with a spoonful of Italian herbs, crushed red pepper, and fresh black pepper—spread it out so every bite pops with flavor.

Oil It Up:

Douse everything (cheese and tomatoes too) with about a quarter cup of solid olive oil for good measure.

Center That Feta:

Put the feta block right in the middle of the pan on top of your tomatoes to set the scene for melting magic.

Tomato First:

Toss two pints of cherry or grape tomatoes in the bottom of a baking dish, letting them cover the base in a thick layer.

Oven Heat Up:

Crank your oven to a hot 400°F so it’s ready to roast the tomatoes and make the feta gooey, but not burnt.

Pin it

I learned firsthand that Greek feta, especially if it’s made with sheep’s milk, gives you the smoothest and boldest flavor. Not long ago, I made this for friends and blew their minds when I shared how few ingredients went into it. It’s wild how much of a difference those sharp, salty feta notes make—turning something simple into something really unforgettable.

Amazing Ways to Serve

Serve your baked feta pasta with some crunchy-yet-tender garlic bread so you can mop up every last drop of that sauce. Round things out with a bowl of crisp arugula greens tossed with olive oil and lemon for some zing. If you’re into wine, a glass of chilled Pinot Grigio or Sauvignon Blanc goes great with the tangy cheese and sweet tomatoes.

Tweak It Your Way

Want to bulk things up? Throw in sliced grilled chicken or toss in some shrimp at the end and mix well. For a Greek vibe, add chopped cucumber, kalamata olives, and a dash of oregano right before serving. If veggies are your jam, stir spinach or arugula into the hot pasta so it wilts right in but doesn’t get soggy.

Keep It for Later

Put leftovers into a sealed storage container and keep them chilled for up to three days. When you’re ready to eat, splash a little water or olive oil over the pasta before reheating so it doesn’t dry out. Heat in the microwave halfway, give it a stir, then finish warming it up. It’s best not to freeze it—the sauce splits and noodles get mushy.

Pro Tips to Try

Hold onto that feta brine and add a spoonful to your pasta water for more oomph inside and out. Roast a whole head of garlic in the pan, then squeeze out the sweet centers into your sauce for a gentle garlic boost. Drizzle top-notch olive oil and a sprinkle of flaky salt right before serving to add a little crunch and amp up the flavors.

Pin it

This baked feta pasta has a permanent spot in my go-to dinner list—not because everyone online can’t stop talking about it, but because it’s truly delicious and so easy. There’s something cool about seeing a few everyday things turn into a dish that’s both cozy and feels a little bit fancy. Even when I’m swamped, I know I can toss this together and end up with something that tastes special without blowing my budget or spending the whole night cooking.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Could I swap in cherry tomatoes?

Totally! Cherry tomatoes are great here. They're even a bit sweeter than grapes and will burst and caramelize just as well in the oven.

→ Don't have a feta block?

Crumble feta will do in a pinch. Just pile it up in the middle of your pan so it melts together while baking.

→ Other pasta shapes okay?

Yep! Use any shape you like—rigatoni, penne, spaghetti. Just cook it till al dente because it'll soak up more sauce.

→ How should I keep the extras?

Stash leftovers in a sealed container and keep in the fridge for up to three days. When reheating, add a splash of olive oil or water to get it creamy again.

→ What mix-ins can I try?

Toss in things like minced garlic, spinach, or sprinkle on red pepper flakes. Toasted pine nuts or a little balsamic on top tastes awesome, too.

→ Can I make this dairy-free?

Sure, try one of the newer dairy-free feta substitutes. Melting might look a little different, but you'll still get a yummy, creamy sauce.