Pin it
Juicy chicken gets packed with smokiness and cooks up in a tasty broth, making a super flexible option for all your go-to Mexican favorites. Each bite is bursting with punchy flavor thanks to a smart combo of classic spices that really get deep into the meat. Giving it a good sear then gently simmering keeps everything really soft but still holds in all that zesty taste. You'll get it on the table in less than half an hour, but everyone will think it's been slow-cooking for ages. Use it in everything from easy tacos to all-out enchiladas—this chicken's ready for anything.
I nailed down this method after spending a month playing around with old-school Mexican cooking ideas. Tried loads of spice combos and ways to cook, but this mix totally hit the mark for real flavor and easy steps. Family asks for it every week now. It’s awesome how you can change up the toppings or sides and suddenly it’s a whole new meal.
Bold Seasonings
- Salt: Pick up some kosher salt—its chunkier pieces stick better and spread out the seasoning while you’re searing.
- Black pepper: Freshly cracked peppercorns have way more flavor and little bit of heat that basic ground pepper never brings.
- Paprika: Sweet paprika from Hungary or Spain works awesome; it adds pretty color and a hint of sweetness but won’t overpower.
- Onion powder: Go for an off-white powder—not too bright—so you know you’re getting real onion flavor, not just sugar.
- Garlic powder: Use pure garlic powder, not garlic salt, so you get all the garlicky taste without too much salt in the mix.
- Oregano: Mexican oregano has a brighter, citrusy kick compared to Mediterranean kinds, which makes the dish pop.
- Cumin: Grinding fresh cumin seeds by yourself gives you bold, earthy flavor that’s super key for this style.
- Chili powder: Get a straight-up chili powder, not a blend—something like ancho or New Mexico is perfect for warmth without too much fire.
Simple Steps
- Soak it up:
- After shredding that chicken, pop it back into whatever sauce is left in the pan—this way every piece gets extra tasty and stays juicy.
- Time to chill:
- Give the chicken five minutes to sit once it's cooked. The juices move back into the meat so nothing dries out.
- Simmer low and slow:
- Keep the heat down. A gentle simmer, not a rolling boil, keeps everything super tender and helps the flavors come together.
- Easy poaching:
- Pour your broth down the side of the pan instead of dumping it right on the chicken so that spice crust stays put.
- Golden crust:
- Wait till the oil just starts to shimmer, then throw in the chicken. That’s how you get tasty crispy bits and seal in all the juice.
- Spice it right:
- Pat chicken dry first, then rub on your spice mix. It’ll stick better and won’t just slide off while cooking.
- Mix it up:
- Whisk all of your spices together in a bowl till the mix looks even—no clumps—so every bite tastes just right.
Pin it
My grandma from Oaxaca always said real Mexican cooking means knowing why each thing goes in. The first time I whipped this up, I didn't bother to toast the spices—big mistake! When I finally tried her hack of warming the spices in a dry pan for just a bit, everything smelled amazing and the taste was next level. Now, I never skip that step. It sounds small, but wow, it helps every flavor shine. Grandma was right—it’s the little things that make it real.
Amazing Ways to Eat It
This chicken fits right in with whatever you're craving. Roll up the spiced meat in corn tortillas, pour some homemade sauce and shredded cheese on top, and bake till it’s sizzling for the ultimate enchiladas. Build a taco salad with crunchy lettuce, black beans, sweet corn, chunks of avo, and top it all off with this chicken plus a squeeze of lime crema. Or go big for your next hangout: set up a taco bar with hot tortillas, this juicy chicken, plus stuff like pickled onions, crumbly cotija, cilantro, and spicy jalapeños—let everyone make their own!
Keep It Fresh
To lock in all that flavor and tenderness, store leftovers right. Put the cooled chicken in a container with some of its sauce left over so it won’t dry out; it’ll stay good in the fridge up to four days. To freeze, use a sturdy zip bag, press it flat for fast thawing, and get the air out—it’ll be great for three months. Save yourself time later by freezing meal-sized portions so you can grab only what you need. Let it thaw overnight in the fridge for best results, or hit defrost in the microwave if you’re in a rush.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use a slow cooker to make this Mexican Pulled Chicken?
- Totally! Just lay the seasoned chicken in your slow cooker, pour in broth, then let it go on low for about 6-7 hours or on high for 3-4 hours. The chicken will get super soft and shreddable. Perfect when you want dinner ready after work.
- → How long can I store Mexican Pulled Chicken in the fridge?
- Stick the cooked shredded chicken in a airtight container and it’ll stay good in your fridge for up to 4 days. Great for making ahead—cook a batch Sunday and use it all week for tacos, bowls, or salads.
- → Is it possible to freeze any leftover Mexican Pulled Chicken?
- For sure! Divide the cooled chicken into freezer bags or containers, squeeze out the air, and freeze it for up to 3 months. Need it? Thaw in your fridge overnight or zap in the microwave. Warm in a skillet with a splash of broth or water so it stays juicy.
- → What’s good to serve with Mexican Pulled Chicken?
- You can pile this chicken into tacos, burritos, tostadas, or quesadillas. Use it for nachos, toss it in salads, or fill bell peppers with chicken and beans. Try it on a Mexican-ish pizza. For low-carb, go with lettuce cups or scoop it over cauliflower rice.
- → Can this be made with chicken breast instead of thighs?
- Thighs and breasts both work just fine here. Thighs usually stay more moist, especially if reheated. If you're using breasts, check them a bit early so they don’t dry out.